December 3, 2025 | 08:09 pm
TEMPO.CO, Jakarta - The civil case between Minister of Agriculture Amran Sulaiman and Tempo, centered on a Rp200 billion lawsuit alleging unlawful acts, has entered a new phase. The Ministry of Agriculture has filed an appeal against the South Jakarta District Court's ruling, which previously granted Tempo's exception as the defendant in a hearing on November 17, 2025.
"The appeal was submitted through e-court on November 28, 2025. The process of scanning the case files is still ongoing," said Asropi, the Second Public Relations Officer at the South Jakarta District Court, when contacted by Tempo on Wednesday, December 3, 2025.
According to the South Jakarta District Court's SIPP page, the request lists the Ministry of Agriculture as the appellant and PT Tempo Inti Media Tbk as the appellee. "The appellee will be notified of this appeal in due course," Asropi confirmed.
Tempo's legal counsel, Mustafa Layong, acknowledged they had not yet received official notification. "We have not received any information about this. Thank you for the update. We will first confirm it in the e-court data," Mustafa stated in a brief message.
The legal counsel for the Ministry of Agriculture, Chandra Muliawan, did not respond to requests for confirmation.
Judge Grants Tempo's Exception
The case began when Minister Amran filed a civil lawsuit, accusing Tempo of committing unlawful acts by not adhering to the Press Council's Statement of Assessment and Recommendation (PPR) concerning a dispute over the cover story titled "Poles-poles Beras Busuk."
The article, which featured a cover image of a rice sack posted on Instagram and X (formerly Twitter), discussed Bulog's policy of purchasing farmers' rice at a single price of Rp6,500 per kilogram.
The panel of judges at the South Jakarta District Court previously ruled in Tempo's favor on November 17, 2025, granting the exception and obliging the Ministry of Agriculture (as the plaintiff) to pay court costs amounting to Rp240,000.
Tempo's Legal Argument for Dismissal
Tempo's legal counsel successfully argued that the South Jakarta District Court lacked the authority to hear the case, citing Law Number 40 of 1999 concerning the Press. They maintained that the Press Council is the institution authorized to resolve such disagreements.
Tempo's legal team further argued that the plaintiff had failed to utilize the right to reply, the right to correction, or report the matter to the Press Council, as mandated by the statutory mechanisms outlined in the Press Law. Additionally, they deemed Amran's lawsuit an Unjustified Lawsuit Against Press (ULAP), suggesting it was lodged with improper intentions.
Tempo's legal team also asserted that the plaintiff lacks legal standing to file the lawsuit. They referenced two main justifications: first, the official complaint to the Press Council was submitted by Wahyu Indarto, not the Minister of Agriculture himself; second, the subject of the dispute, namely the news coverage, did not directly implicate Amran but rather focused on Bulog's activities related to rice and/or paddy absorption.
Tempo's legal team characterized the lawsuit as an abuse of rights, citing indications of coercion through the exorbitant demand for Rp200 billion in compensation. They also claimed that Amran's lawsuit was directed against the incorrect entity because the disputed news was published by tempo.co under PT Info Media Digital, not PT Tempo Inti Media Tbk.
Tempo's team stressed that Minister Amran, acting as a government official, cannot sue on behalf of ministry employees, Bulog, or Indonesian farmers without an explicit legal mandate.
Nabiila Azzahra contributed to the report
Read: South Jakarta Court Grants Tempo's Exception in Amran Sulaiman's Rp200bn Lawsuit
Click here to get the latest news updates from Tempo on Google News
Fact Check: Claim That Malaysia Has No Rice Supply is Misleading
1 hari lalu
Fact check - A video circulating on TikTok claims that Malaysia does not have enough rice to meet the needs of its population.
Indonesia Investigates 250 Tons of Allegedly Illegal Rice Imported via Sabang Port
8 hari lalu
Indonesia has responded to the discovery of 250 tons of allegedly illegal rice, with Customs chief saying his agency did not authorize the import.
Amran Sulaiman's Relationship with Haji Isam
15 hari lalu
Amran Sulaiman and Andi Syamsuddin Arsyad have a kinship relationship. They work together on a food project in Southeast Sulawesi.
Amran Sulaiman's Opportunity in the Political Arena
15 hari lalu
Amran Sulaiman nearly led the United Development Party. Prabowo Subianto was taken with him because of his food-sector programs
South Jakarta Court Grants Tempo's Exception in Amran Sulaiman's Rp200bn Lawsuit
16 hari lalu
The South Jakarta District Court declared that they don't have the authority to adjudicate the case between Tempo and Minister Amran Sulaiman.
A House Commission's Criticism of the Agriculture Minister
16 hari lalu
The DPR and the Ombudsman question the policies of Agriculture Minister Amran Sulaiman after discovering suboptimal rice management.
Amran Sulaiman's Agricultural Populism
16 hari lalu
Food self-sufficiency is being achieved through populist policies. Like foam on the ocean.
Central Sulawesi Journalists Urge Court to Dismiss Amran's Case Against Tempo
16 hari lalu
Journalists in Central Sulawesi believe that the Tempo case will set a precedent for other media outlets.
Amran Sulaiman: Does Rice Production Increase or Not?
16 hari lalu
Amran Sulaiman claims that the Agriculture Ministry is capable of achieving its production target and avoiding rice import.
International Rights Group Urges Prabowo to Halt Minister's Lawsuit Against Tempo
21 hari lalu
International Freedom of Expression (IFEX) argues that the lawsuit by Prabowo's Minister Amran against Tempo undermines democracy in Indonesia.
